echoes of violence, voices of change

Art in its Contemporary Setting
Taught by Kyra Rice

10th Grade at Dolores Huerta High
27 students

daily lesson plans


MONDAY - week one
OBJECTIVE
Giving Students Voice, Create Class Manifesto: Students will have defined the terms, values, conditions and rules of this classroom's cultural environment in a class manifesto. Create journal covers with manifesto written on it.

Create Journal Covers with Manifesto: covers constructed out of a choice of papers that teacher brings to class. The class manifesto will be written/displayed on journal covers.

INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS
Students already have journals for this class and are to bring them to class every day. Teacher will bring to class at least 40 pieces of paper from my collection for journal covers. Glue stick for Victor (see special considerations). Colored pencils and markers are already in class. One journal cover decorated and assembled for demonstration. Computer in class for student who has special writing needs.

SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS
There is a student, Victor, who has Multiple Sclerosis and has difficulty with tactile motor skills, although he can type relatively well. He has a journal that is designed so that you may insert blank pages for sketches and printed pages for journal entries. I will encourage Victor to do as much as he can and offer assistance when he needs it with folding and placing cover onto his journal. I will offer Victor the option of typing out the manifesto and pasting it to journal cover, but he will be encouraged to design background with colored pencils and markers himself.

PROCEDURES
- 35 minutes: class gets settled, teacher to ask students what they understand the word "manifesto" to mean, writing volunteers' responses on the board.
When no more volunteers the teacher will write standard American dictionary definition of the word "manifesto" on board. Teacher will ask students to consider a manifesto for this class room's cultural environment with the objective of creating a "safe space" for students to talk openly and freely about journal reflections, and personal and artistic issues as they relate to their artworks. Class will engage in discussion. As the discussion evolves students will be asked to write down any issues that come up for them that may be important to consider for the class manifesto. Teacher will also participate in discussion and journal note taking, revealing her own thoughts, issues and conditions for a safe classroom culture. Rules of the manifesto will be enumerated and written on board by a volunteer to be copied by each student and written on their journal covers.
- 5 minutes: teacher will demonstrate how to fold and put on journal covers from one she brought to class.
- 15 minutes: students will choose paper, and begin to design and assemble journal covers. Manifesto is to be written on the cover of the journal. If not completed, they have manifesto written down and can complete at home as homework, designs may evolve throughout semester.

SAMPLE STUDENT PRODUCTS
Students will have defined a safe space for themselves and for group the group as a whole. Students valus and goals for the class will be defined as a group and will be visibly written on their journal covers as their own class manifesto.

ASSESSMENT
Every day throughout semester participation will be assessed on a scale of 1 to 3 points. 3 points if participated and engaged, 2 points if engaged but participating minimally, 1 points if participating but not in an effective way that dispalys the student is engaged with issue at hand, no credit if disruptive, and/or never participated, had nothing to add when called upon and seemed disengaged.

Final outcome of class manifesto will be graded as credit for entire group if completed by end of class and 1/2 credit if it flows over to next day because of a lack of student participation.

The journals will be assessed throughout the semester (including cover design) each week for credit if being used as suggested by teacher, or no credit if student fails to use it as a resource each week. Teacher will assess and take notes on each student's journal each week.

REFLECTION
By having it visible at all times on student journal covers, the safe space manifesto frames all of the written and reflective work students will do in their journals.
With the manifesto journal covers I am intentionally making them highly visible with the hope that it might stimulate conversation for my students outside of the class with other students, friends and family so that they can continue the discourse on what it means to honor a safe space for open dialogue.

Another aspect of the student creation of the manifesto is to begin engaging the students in critical thinking skills; discussing and clarifying class objectives, assesing thier own and others' conditions and rules as appropriate or not tose objectives.

LITERACY ASPECT
Students will be "speaking out loud" about what is necessary for them to feel safe when discussing personal issues as they relate to violence, current events and their own art. Discussion will foster an environment where students will be exploring what makes them feel safe or not. As the discussion evolves students will be writing any issues that come up for them, that did not get addressed in the discussion, that may be important to consider for the class manifesto. Teacher will also participate in discussion and journal note taking, revealing her own thoughts, vulnerabilities and conditions. Students and teacher together will thereby be creating the safe space they need as their terms and conditions are revealed, defined and implemented then written out as the class manifesto encasing (enshrining even) the journal work they do.

TUESDAY - week one
OBJECTIVE
Students should have basic understanding of the term "propaganda" and how art was used as propaganda during WW1.

INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS
Slide projector, slides of WW1 era art works, slide list, prepared lecture notes on slide show, instructor's journal.

PROCEDURES
- 25 minutes: slide show and lecture. Students to be taking notes.
- 3 minutes: revisit "safe space" class manifesto
- 15 minutes: class discussion of key points of slide show and notes that students took during sideshow lecture. Teacher will remind and emphasize key points of lecture if I do not hear the students addressing them during discussion from their notes.
- 7 minutes: students will sketch and write expressing how the material makes them feel and what they think on a personal level about material covered.

SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS
Victor will use computer to type his journal reflections and notes on lecture. Blank pages have been inserted for any sketches he may want to do. Help Victor insert his printed pages at end of class.

SAMPLE STUDENT PRODUCTS
Students will leave class knowing how to define "propaganda"—with a written definition in their journals—and how it was used in the arts during WW1 era. They will also have written reflective thoughts about material covered. An example journal reflection would be: "I never knew what 'propaganda' meant. Now that I do I feel like I can understand what is presented to me in some of the arts and in advertising a little more; what I see could be some politician's opinion or agenda they are trying to push on me....instead of just seeing it and thinking 'that's just the way things are.' I'm really glad that I know this!"

ASSESSMENT
To be determined in weekly journal assessment. Participation to be assessed each day as described on Monday.

REFLECTION
What I am hoping for toady is that with this issue of propaganda the students will understand that they can in fact take a more critical look at the visual culture they are immersed in and know that what they see is not necessarily what IS. I hope this will empower them to some extent in the direction of the projects that follow about commentary and encourages the students to eventually take an active role in the creation of their visual culture...not just be subordinate to it..

LITERACY ASPECT
-homework 1. Journal writing: Where do you see propaganda used in our world today? What forms does it come in? Can you identify it? How do you feel about propaganda when you identify it; do you believe in it? do you let it influence the way you think about an issue? never, always, sometimes?
-Students will be asked to take notes on slide show and lecture as a means to understanding propaganda and WW1 era art.
-Class discussion of notes taken during lecture
-End of class journal reflection: sketches and/or writing expressing how the material makes them feel, what they think on a personal level about material covered.

WEDNESDAY - week one
OBJECTIVE
1. read local news

2. Reveal the similarities (propaganda) and differences (presentation) in what is produced in the arts today as compared and contrasted with WW1 era art.

3. Familiarity with format of the post card during WW1 era and its propagandistic power.

INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS
Slide projector, slides of WW1 era post cards, slide list, prepared lecture notes on slide show, list of venues for student to find post cards locally, instructor's journal.

PROCEDURES
-25 minutes: students present their findings from homework. Ask the question 'what is and what is not propaganda?'. Create a more thorough understanding of their knoeledge of propaganda as it was used in WW1 era and apply that knowledge to their contemporary findings.
- 15 minutes: present slide show of Post card art of WW1 era. Students take more notes on what the different imagery means or implies.
- 10 minutes: explain homework (see literacy aspect bellow) .

SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS
Victor will be using computer for note taking. It is very important at this point to try to make the discussions as engaging as possible, and the slide shows INTERESTING for these kids. The first few days of this unit are quite academically challenging. I do not want to loose Tavious and Rosa!

SAMPLE STUDENT PRODUCTS
Students will have an expanded understanding of the power of the post card for propagandistic use. Sample journal note: "Post card were the only way that people could communicate with each other over seas. Every person who was at war and every family member who wanted to communicate with loved ones would send post cards...that's A LOT of post cards circulating around the world! And a lot of people who were vulnerable to their loved ones at war and the patriotism of those guys fighting, all looking at and being influenced by the stuff on the cards."

From the homework they will be able to identify propaganda in their own surroundings and begin thinking more critically about their visual culture. Example journal reflection: "I saw a commercial on TV about some SUV and it said that it was 'the American way of life...something to be proud of.' Well I am an American and our family only owns one small car that my mom has to take to work. My brother and I have to take the bus to school..and my dad is all about 'fuel efficiency'. Are we less American because we do not own a SUV? I'm proud of our life without no SUV!" This would be a great discussion catalyst for the war in Iraq, the US's oil interests as associated with US value in oil and a guilt free excessive oil consumption...who knows where the conversation will go. The point is to encourage the kids to start thinking more abstractly and conceptually about their visual culture so that they can begin to participate and take an active role in it—through advertising or the arts.

ASSESSMENT
To be determined in weekly journal assessment. Participation to be assessed each day as described on Monday.

REFLECTION
I know that a lot of these students do not have much support for their school work at home and I am concerned that even as they watch TV—which could be a source for their homework—they will forget or just not to do their journal reflections. I hope that the kids that DO come to class with reflections will encourage the kids that are not, that it is not that hard, that what I am asking is that they look more carefully and critically at what they are already staring at every day.

LITERACY ASPECT
-Discussion of students journal reflection homework, note taking during slide show with follow-up discussion of key points.

-homework:
1. find, read and write a summary on current event form newspaper, news magazine, or the web

2a. FOR Friday students are asked to bring in 3 postcards from 3 different venues. Give students a list of recourses where they can find post cards: Quantity Post Cards in North Beach, art gallery stores; card stores, parties or all ages clubs will have promotional post cards, etc. AT LEAST ONE OF THEM HAS TO ADDRESS ISSUE OF VIOLENCE, CURRENT WAR /EVENTS, OR WW1.

2b. Write journal entries for each: -discussing formal elements: materials used, composition, type of art or representation, propaganda? commentary? beauty? etc., - why student chose that piece; what they like, dislike; what they think about the content; and what venue they found each post card in. Bring post cards to class. Due next Monday.

THURSDAY - week one
OBJECTIVE
Students understand some of the origins of violence from material covered so far as well as current war situation and events.

INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS
Journals, news paper article addressing local violence or current war situation. Prepared discussion points and question for class discussion

PROCEDURES
-5 minutes: revisit class manifesto
-10 minutes: students present current events.
-
25 minutes: engage discussion, encourage students to talk about the violence that occurs in their lives. Must be handled with delicacy. Ask if what is going on in the world today, in their homes, in their 'hood, in the country, and in this moment in history have any connection. Most importantly discuss what we can do to eliminate violence from our community, and interactions. Give students a list of community outreach services for youth of domestic violence
- last few minutes: begin a drawing/painting in journal of your reaction to today's discussion, finish tonight as homework. This can be in any medium and any style—expressionist, cartoon, impressionist, literal/figurative, etc. Also encourage students to think about today's discussion when being out there in the community and finding their post cards.

SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS
Must be extremely sensitive to the fact that some students come from households that have domestic violence and others who can not even imagine that but are well aware of the violence that has been occurring within their own communities. If a student reveals domestic violence at home (because we have done such a great job of creating a "safe space" for open dialogue!) I will talk to the student privately, offer help from a specialist, as well as inform him or her of community outreach services for youth of domestic violence. I will also report it to the principal.

SAMPLE STUDENT PRODUCTS
Students will leave class with a knowledge of how community, society and political climate have an influence on individual lives and may contribute to stress at home and in the streets. Students will have different perspectives on eliminating violence as well as beginning to think about how they can have an active roll in eliminating it from AT LEAST their own interactions. Sample Journal reflection: student sketches an image of a waist sight, a large hole in the ground that is filled with guns to be buried. People of many races are gathering at the hole and dumping their guns into the hole voluntarily. A large tractor is drawn at the edge of the image with its shovel full of dirt raised over the hole.

ASSESSMENT
To be determined in weekly journal assessment. Participation to be assessed each day as described on Monday.

REFLECTION
My hope is that students will become aware of the fact that their are alternatives to violence—even though it is present in society and throughout history—but there is help out there if they are subject to it or inclined in that way.

LITERACY ASPECT
-Revisit class manifesto
-discus istudent summaries on current events with student note taking
-discus issues of violence in our everyday lives as it applies to current events, students and teacher take notes on discussion
-discus students' notes and key points.

FRIDAY - week one

OBJECTIVE
1. Students will have a clear understanding of the fact that with careful observation and critically thinking about what is going on around them they can have an impact on their worlds through their own art and expression.

2. Overcome any obstacles students may me encountering with material or homework.

-INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS
-
Post card collection for students to choose from. Here are a few examples:


A dog, carrying a piece of meat in his mouth, saw the reflection of it in the water; and snatching at the shadow lost the meat itself... ... German has lost the prosperity she had so laboriously acquired in the vain endeavor to obtain the mastery of the world.

 

1918: Austrian Fieldpost. Lithographed postcard. Scarcer lithographed postcard from W.W.1 depicting a soldier with Austro Hungarian eagles.

W.W.I.: The flags of the French Infantry troops
litho, These are actually the first enemy flags (German) captured by the French at the onset of WW1.

W.W.I. Self made Field Post Card ­ 1916: A piece of bark from a birch tree was the material for this unusual piece of postal history. An additional piece of moss has been added.

 

Man on horse, "Die Heim..." (Ludwig Koch 1918) The postcard shows a man famous for wondering the trenches and taking injured men to medical aid.

(example of WW1 Poast card art that is not propaganda in nature)

WW1: Mocking card Russian Tsar in Galicia Ca. 1916: "What the Giant did in Galicia". postcard depicting the Russian Czar blowing away the European soldiers.

6th Austrian War Bond: M. Lenz, Postcard Saint George on a white stallion fighting against a dragon. This postcards was issued by the K.K. priv. Wiener Bank Verein for promotion of the 6th Austrian War Bond.


The card above I threw in because it is exemplary of how creative and expressive a person can be under the most daunting of circumstances.

 

- List of web sites for students to research WW1 post cards
1. Propaganda Post Cards: http://www.ww1-propaganda-cards.com/
2. The World In a Post Card: http://members.ozemail.com.au/~rodeime/postcards/
3. Graphic Witeness: Visual Arts and Social Commentary: http://www.graphicwitness.org/ineye/pcs5c.htm
4. WW1: An Almost Forgotten Language: http://www.diggerhistory.info/pages-slang/ww1.htm

- List of hip-hop sites relevent to social commentary:
1. Latino hip-hop at Bownpride.com: http://www.brownpride.com/
2. Asian-American social commentary at About.com: http://chineseculture.about.com/cs/socialcommentary/
3. Boogie Down Productions: http://www.mp3.com/boogie-down-productions/artists/12/summary.html
4. RapNews.net: http://www.rapnewsdirect.com/News/2004/11/01/Rap.Soc.Cons/
5. Isreal in the 21st Century: http://www.cicweb.ca/Israel21century/arts/hiphop.cfm

-instructor's journal

PROCEDURES
- 3 minutes: revisit class manifesto

- 10 minutes: have students volunteer to show and discus their journal art from yesterday's discussion. (Not all students need to show their work with class.)

- 25 minutes: Present post card collection. Given the background they now have, have students formulate 2 - 4 questions regarding how these peices are propagandistic in nature. Begin discussion and answering questions as students formulate questions.

- 15 minutes: Explain homework assignment for next week: 1a. - students will choose 3 post cards from collection that teacher brings (or 2, and 1 of the three they find themselves from Wed.'s homework). 1b. Research‹from class lecture notes or the web. Write a list on board of web sites where students can research the cards they chose and a list of rap and social commentary sites (see instructional materials for list). Student are to describe each: imagery, formal elements, historical content, and message. 1c. write personal commentary, poem, song or rap about ONE card. (if you need inspiration or insight go to the web sites listed.) TWO OF THESE POST CARDS WILL BE DISPLAYED AT THE ARMISTICE FAIR AND YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO PERFORM YOUR RAP OR SPOKEN WORD.
OR
2a. Create a post card that addresses the issue of VIOLENCE, CURRENT EVENTS/WAR SITUATION, OR WW1. 2b. preliminary sketch of imagery you choose, materials you will use, and describe the content/ propaganda or message. 2c. Write personal commentary in the form of a poem, song or rap that will accompany your post card. TO BE DISPLAYED AT THE ARMISTICE FAIR AND YOU WILL BE PERFORMING YOUR RAP/SPOKEN WORD. Due next Thursday.

SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS
If students feel overloaded with the homework I will consider reducing the number of cards from Wednesday's homework from 3 to 1. If student only does one then post card must have to do with violence or war and I will direct them to Quantity Post Cards in North Beach in that case.

ASSESSMENT
This assignment will be graded "A - F". If students designed their own post card they will be graded "A - F" for each portion‹the post card and the research/commentary. If the student did a thorough job of note taking in class Tuesday and Wednesday (the lecture and slide show on those days covered all of the imagery on the post cards that teacher brought into class today) or researched the post card thoroughly from web links provided; wrote thoughtful commentary in the form of spoken word or a rap student will receive an "A". If they created there own post card and the image presents some kind of comment on the relevant issues and is well crafted student will receive an "A." If students rap is relevant to the imagery and provides some social commentary they will receive and "A" for the commentary portion of their grade.

If student did all research but not a thorough job of it, but have a relevant rap they will receive a "B". If student left out some of the research and does not have commentary that is applicable to the post card they will receive a "C" for effort and time put into it. Any effort less than the "C" or incomplete work will receive a "D". Incomplete projects where no research has been done and no commentary written will receive and "F".

SAMPLE STUDENT PRODUCTS
Taviuos designs his own post card with imagery of violence and destruction, a lot of blood and gore and weapons. He performs a rap about how the violence is "killin' me...it's killin' me." In his journal he defines the images, materials he used and the content of the imagery. This post card is very literal and direct in it's display of violence but lacks commentary; it simply is a display of violence. The rap addresses the social commentary very well however. This project would receive an "A-" only because I would have liked to have seen the post card imagery present some commentary on the violence in addition to a depiction of the violence itself. His rap successfully achieved that end. By just looking at the card I can not tell if he is "getting into" the violence or trying to reveal it. We see these images of violence around us all the time...what is his image trying to say?

REFLECTION
The idea here is to get the students involved in making art that gives them a voice in their worlds.

LITERACY ASPECT
- Discuss how students as artists can have an impact on their immediate surroundings and in the greater societal picture with their own commentary.

VOICE ACTIVATION:
- WW1 post card research from notes or web resources provided in class.
- commentary in the form of a spoken word or rap. .

back to top

Music
week 1
week 2
week 3
week 4
lesson plans
assessment

French
week 1

week 2
week 3
week 4

lesson plans
assessment

Art
week 1

week 2
week 3
week 4
lesson plans

assessment

Social Science
week 1

week 2
week 3
week 4
lesson plans
assessment

Science
week 1

week 2
week 3
week 4
lesson plans
assessment

Culminating
Activity:

Armistice Fair